13 Warning Signs of Identity Theft

• 15 min read

Identity theft isn’t always obvious. You might notice an unfamiliar charge on your bank statement, receive a bill for an account you never opened, or suddenly lose access to an online account. Sometimes, the first warning sign appears months after someone steals your personal information.

Stressed woman holding her head at her laptop

The sooner you recognize suspicious activity, the better your chances of limiting the damage. Here are 13 warning signs of identity theft, how to check whether someone has misused your information, and what to do if you discover fraud.

How to Tell If Someone Is Using Your Identity

Identity theft happens when someone uses your personal information without permission, often to obtain money, credit, services, or benefits. A thief might open new accounts in your name, take over accounts you already have, or use your Social Security number for tax fraud.

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) identifies several warning signs that can help you recognize identity theft. Some provide strong evidence of fraud, while others mean you should investigate further.

1. You Find Accounts on Your Credit Report That You Didn’t Open

One of the clearest warning signs of identity theft is a credit card, loan, or other account on your credit report that you don’t recognize.

Someone might use your name and Social Security number to apply for credit. You may discover the account through an unfamiliar credit inquiry, a new balance, or a late payment on your credit report.

Fraudulent accounts can also affect your credit score. For example, a credit card with a high balance could increase your credit utilization ratio and lower your credit score.

What to do: Review your credit reports from Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. If you find an unfamiliar account, contact the lender’s fraud department to verify it. Report any confirmed fraud and dispute the fraudulent information with the credit bureaus.

2. You See Unauthorized Charges or Bank Withdrawals

An unfamiliar transaction on your bank or credit card statement could mean someone has gained access to your account information.

Watch for purchases you didn’t make, transfers you didn’t authorize, and withdrawals from unfamiliar locations. Even small transactions deserve attention because thieves sometimes test stolen payment information before attempting larger purchases.

Not every unfamiliar charge is fraudulent. A merchant might use a different business name, or a family member might have made a purchase on a shared account.

What to do: Check the merchant details and confirm the transaction isn’t legitimate. If you still don’t recognize it, contact your bank or credit card issuer immediately. Report the transaction through its official fraud process and ask whether you need a replacement card or account number.

Don’t delay. Federal protections against unauthorized transactions depend partly on the type of account and how quickly you notify the financial institution.

3. You Receive Bills or Debt Collection Calls for Unfamiliar Accounts

A bill for an account you never opened is a serious warning sign. The same applies if a debt collector contacts you about money you don’t owe.

Someone might have opened a credit card, taken out a loan, or obtained services in your name. You might not discover the account until the payments become overdue and a collection agency gets involved.

However, collection notices can also result from clerical errors or mistaken identity. You’ll need to verify the debt before you can determine what happened.

What to do: Ask the debt collector for information about the account and the original creditor. You have the right to request debt validation and dispute debts that aren’t yours.

If you confirm identity theft, notify the original creditor and the collection agency. Request that the fraudulent account be closed and that any inaccurate credit report information be corrected.

4. You’re Denied Credit Unexpectedly

If a lender rejects your credit card or loan application when you expected approval, identity theft is one possible explanation.

Someone might have opened fraudulent accounts in your name or accumulated unpaid debts that hurt your credit score. You could also have unfamiliar inquiries or inaccurate personal information on your credit report.

A denial doesn’t automatically mean someone stole your identity. Lenders also consider income, existing debts, credit history, and their own approval requirements.

What to do: Read the adverse action notice from the lender. It should explain the main reasons for the decision and identify the credit bureau that supplied the credit report information, if applicable.

You can request a free credit report after certain credit denials. Check for accounts, inquiries, or other information that doesn’t belong to you.

5. You Receive Account Change Notifications You Didn’t Request

Banks, credit card issuers, and other companies often send notifications when someone changes important account details.

An unexpected email or text about a new password, mailing address, phone number, or recovery email address might mean someone has gained access to your account.

For example, a thief who changes your recovery email address might make it harder for you to regain access later.

However, the notification itself could be a phishing attempt. Fraudsters sometimes send fake security alerts to trick people into entering passwords or other sensitive information.

What to do: Don’t click links or call phone numbers in an unexpected notification. Instead, open the company’s official app or website and check your account settings.

If someone changed your information without permission, secure the account and contact the company’s fraud or security department. You can find official contact details for the three nationwide credit bureaus in our credit bureau contact information guide.

6. You Can’t Access an Account You Normally Use

If your usual password suddenly stops working, someone might have changed it without your permission.

Account takeover can affect email accounts, financial accounts, shopping accounts, and other online services. Email account access is especially sensitive because someone could use it to reset passwords for other accounts.

Of course, a failed login doesn’t always indicate identity theft. You might have entered the wrong password, or the company might be experiencing technical problems.

What to do: Try the account’s official recovery process and review any recent security notifications. If you suspect unauthorized access, contact the company’s security department.

Once you regain access, change your password, review your recovery information, and check for unfamiliar activity. Secure other accounts that share the same password.

7. You Receive Login Alerts or Security Codes You Didn’t Request

An unexpected verification code or login alert could mean someone is attempting to access one of your accounts.

For example, you might receive a text with a six-digit security code even though you haven’t tried to sign in. You could also receive an authenticator app notification that asks you to approve a login.

These alerts don’t necessarily mean someone successfully accessed your account. They might indicate a failed attempt, a password reset request, or an accidental login attempt by another person.

What to do: Never share an unexpected verification code or approve a login you didn’t initiate. Check your account’s recent security activity through its official website or app.

If you find suspicious activity, change your password and end unfamiliar sessions. Keep multifactor authentication enabled.

8. Your Regular Bills or Important Mail Stop Arriving

If bills or important letters suddenly stop arriving, someone might have changed your mailing address without permission.

Identity thieves sometimes redirect mail to hide fraudulent accounts or prevent you from receiving account statements. Someone might also steal mail directly from your mailbox.

A missing bill could have an innocent explanation, such as a postal delay or an accidental switch to paperless statements. But repeated problems deserve attention.

What to do: Contact the companies that normally send your bills and confirm the mailing addresses on your accounts. Ask whether anyone recently changed your contact information.

If you suspect someone redirected your mail, contact the U.S. Postal Service. Review your financial accounts for unauthorized changes or transactions.

9. You Receive a Credit Card or Account Welcome Letter You Didn’t Request

A credit card, welcome letter, or account-opening confirmation from an unfamiliar financial institution could mean someone applied for credit in your name.

A thief might have submitted an application with your personal information and used your actual address. You could discover the account when the company sends its first communication.

Don’t confuse a preapproved credit card offer with confirmation that an account has opened. Marketing offers generally don’t mean someone successfully obtained credit in your name.

What to do: Contact the financial institution through its official website or published phone number. Ask whether an account exists in your name and whether an application was submitted.

If the application was fraudulent, request that the institution close the account and document the identity theft. Check all three credit reports for additional unfamiliar accounts or inquiries.

10. Your Tax Return Is Rejected or You Receive an Unexpected IRS Notice

Tax identity theft happens when someone uses your personal information to file a fraudulent tax return or commit other tax-related fraud.

One warning sign is an electronically filed tax return rejection because the IRS already received a return with your Social Security number.

You might also receive an unexpected IRS notice about a tax return, income from an unfamiliar employer, or a tax transcript you never requested.

These problems don’t always mean identity theft. Filing errors and other tax issues can cause similar notices.

What to do: Confirm that your tax return information is correct and follow the instructions from the IRS. If you receive an unexpected notice, contact the IRS through the phone number on the notice or its official website.

You can also contact the IRS Identity Protection Specialized Unit at 800-908-4490.

Depending on your situation, the IRS might instruct you to submit Form 14039, Identity Theft Affidavit. Follow the IRS instructions for your specific situation rather than automatically submitting the form.

11. You Receive Medical Bills or Insurance Claims for Care You Didn’t Get

Medical identity theft occurs when someone uses your personal or health insurance information to obtain medical services, prescriptions, or other benefits.

You might receive a bill for a medical procedure you never had or notice an unfamiliar claim in your insurance account.

In some cases, medical identity theft can create incorrect information in your medical records. This could cause problems with future treatment or insurance claims.

For example, your insurer might reject a legitimate claim because its records show benefits you never used.

What to do: Contact the medical provider and your health insurance company. Request information about the unfamiliar services and ask how to dispute the charges or claims.

Review your medical records for incorrect information and request corrections where necessary. Keep copies of your correspondence and any documents that support your dispute.

12. You Can’t Open a Utility Account Because of an Unfamiliar Debt

Identity thieves can use stolen personal information to open electricity, gas, phone, internet, and other utility accounts.

You might discover the fraud when a utility company refuses to open an account because you supposedly owe money from a previous address.

For example, someone could establish service under your name, accumulate unpaid bills, and disappear. You might not learn about the debt until you try to obtain service yourself.

What to do: Ask the utility provider for details about the account and the address where service was established. Explain that you suspect identity theft if you don’t recognize the account.

Request a fraud investigation and ask the provider how to dispute the debt. You may also need to correct inaccurate information with any consumer reporting agency that received the fraudulent account details.

13. You Receive Notices About Unemployment Benefits or Income You Didn’t Earn

Someone who steals your Social Security number might use it to claim unemployment benefits or report employment income under your identity.

You might receive a Form 1099-G for unemployment benefits you never collected. Your employer could also notify you about an unemployment claim you didn’t submit.

Another warning sign is a Form W-2 from a company you’ve never worked for or an IRS notice about income you don’t recognize.

These situations can create tax problems if government records incorrectly associate someone else’s income or benefits with your identity.

What to do: Contact the state unemployment agency if someone filed a fraudulent benefits claim in your name. Notify your employer if the claim involves your current employment.

For unfamiliar wages or tax documents, follow the IRS instructions for employment-related identity theft. You should also consider the possibility that someone has misused your Social Security number for other purposes.

How to Check If Someone Has Stolen Your Identity

One suspicious transaction or unexpected notification doesn’t automatically mean your identity has been stolen. The next step is to look for evidence that someone has actually used your information without permission.

Several accounts and records can help you determine whether fraud has occurred.

  • Credit reports: Request your free credit reports from Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. Check for unfamiliar accounts, credit inquiries, balances, and personal information. You can currently obtain a free credit report from each nationwide credit bureau every week.
  • Bank and credit card accounts: Review recent transactions, transfers, payment methods, and account changes. Check statements from accounts you don’t use frequently.
  • Email and online accounts: Review recent login activity, security notifications, recovery email addresses, and connected devices. Look for password changes or account access you didn’t authorize.
  • IRS account: Review tax information through your official IRS online account. Investigate unfamiliar tax notices, returns, or income documents.
  • Health insurance account: Examine recent claims and benefit statements. Contact your insurer if you find medical services or prescriptions you didn’t receive.

Pay particular attention if you notice multiple warning signs at the same time. For example, an unfamiliar credit account combined with a new debt collection notice may provide stronger evidence of identity theft than an unexpected credit score change alone.

If you confirm unauthorized activity, act quickly to protect the affected accounts.

What to Do If You Notice Signs of Identity Theft

Your response depends on the type of identity theft and which accounts are affected. However, several steps can help you stop additional fraud, document what happened, and correct the damage.

1. Contact the Companies Where Fraud Occurred

Start with the bank, lender, service provider, or other company connected to the suspicious activity.

Contact its fraud department through an official phone number or website. Explain what happened and ask the company to investigate.

If someone took over an existing account, ask the company to secure it. If someone opened an account in your name, request that the fraudulent account be closed.

Change compromised passwords and security information. Keep records of the dates, people you contacted, case numbers, and responses you received.

2. Place a Credit Freeze or Fraud Alert

A credit freeze and a fraud alert can help protect you from additional credit-related identity theft, but they work differently.

A credit freeze restricts access to your credit report. This makes it harder for someone to open new credit accounts in your name. Credit freezes are free, don’t affect your credit score, and remain in place until you lift them.

You’ll need to contact Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion separately to freeze your credit.

A fraud alert tells potential lenders to take additional steps to verify your identity before granting credit. An initial fraud alert is free and lasts one year. You only need to contact one nationwide credit bureau, which must notify the other two.

A credit freeze generally provides stronger protection against new credit accounts, but neither option prevents every type of identity theft. Neither will stop someone who already has access to your existing accounts.

3. Report Identity Theft to the FTC

If someone has stolen your identity, visit IdentityTheft.gov to report it to the Federal Trade Commission.

The website helps you create an FTC Identity Theft Report and a recovery plan based on your situation.

Your FTC Identity Theft Report can help when you dispute fraudulent accounts, request corrections to your credit reports, or deal with companies that need proof of identity theft.

You can also call the FTC at 877-438-4338 for assistance.

A police report isn’t necessary in every identity theft case. However, it may be appropriate if you know who stole your identity, a company requests one, or the theft involves criminal impersonation or other circumstances that require law enforcement assistance.

4. Dispute Fraudulent Accounts and Credit Report Information

If identity theft affects your credit reports, contact the credit bureaus that display the fraudulent information.

Explain which accounts or transactions aren’t yours and submit the documentation necessary to support your dispute.

Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, you can also request that a credit bureau block information that resulted from identity theft. The credit bureau generally must block qualifying information within four business days after receiving the required documents.

You’ll typically need proof of identity, an identity theft report, identification of the fraudulent information, and a statement that the transactions weren’t yours.

You should also contact the company that supplied the fraudulent information. Ask it to investigate and stop reporting inaccurate account details.

5. Resolve Any Other Identity Theft Problems

Some types of identity theft require additional action beyond credit protection.

For tax identity theft, work with the IRS. For medical identity theft, contact the affected providers and health insurer. If someone claimed unemployment benefits in your name, report the fraud to the appropriate state agency.

If unauthorized charges affected your bank or credit card account, follow the financial institution’s dispute process promptly. Your liability rights depend on the type of account, applicable law, and the timing of your notification.

Continue to review your accounts after the initial fraud investigation. Identity theft can involve multiple accounts, and additional unauthorized activity may appear later.

How to Protect Yourself From Identity Theft

You can’t prevent every data breach or identity theft attempt, but you can take steps to make your personal information harder to misuse.

Use unique passwords for important accounts and store them in a trusted password manager. Enable multifactor authentication, preferably through an authenticator app or security key when supported. Review account security settings and don’t share verification codes with anyone.

Keep documents with sensitive information in a secure place. Be careful about where you provide your Social Security number, and shred paperwork that contains personal or financial details before discarding it.

Review your bank statements and credit reports regularly. A free credit freeze can provide additional protection against fraudulent credit applications, even if you haven’t experienced identity theft.

You can also consider a credit monitoring service or an identity theft protection service. These services may notify you about certain suspicious changes or offer recovery assistance.

However, paid protection isn’t required to access your free credit reports, place credit freezes, or report identity theft to the FTC.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can someone steal your identity without affecting your credit report?

Yes. Someone can use your personal information for medical treatment, tax fraud, unemployment benefits, or unauthorized access to existing accounts without creating a new account on your credit report.

That’s why a clean credit report doesn’t guarantee your identity is safe. You should also check financial transactions, tax notices, medical claims, and account security alerts for unfamiliar activity.

How can you tell if someone has stolen your child’s identity?

Warning signs of child identity theft include unexpected bills, collection notices, credit card offers that suggest an existing credit history, or IRS notices about your child’s Social Security number.

Children generally don’t have credit reports. If you suspect identity theft, you can ask each nationwide credit bureau to check whether a credit report exists under your child’s information.

If you discover fraudulent accounts, contact the companies involved and report the identity theft to the FTC. You can also request a free credit freeze for your child through each nationwide credit bureau.

Miranda Marquit
Meet the author

Miranda Marquit is a financial writer and podcaster who has covered personal finance and investing since 2006. She holds an M.A. in journalism and an MBA. Her reporting has appeared on NPR's Marketplace and Morning Edition, and in Forbes, MarketWatch, Yahoo Finance, and Buy Side from The Wall Street Journal, where she has worked as a senior editor.