Does Paying Off Collections Improve My Credit Score?


Credit scores play a crucial role in personal finance, determining your eligibility for loans and affecting the interest rates you receive. This comprehensive guide will explore the impact of paying off collections on your credit score, examine various credit scoring models, and offer valuable advice to help you regain control of your finances.

couple on laptop

Understanding Collections and Credit Scores

What are collections?

When a debt goes unpaid, the original creditor may sell it to a collection agency, which then attempts to recover the debt from the consumer. Collections can involve various types of debts, such as credit card debt, medical bills, and utility bills, among others.

How Collections Affect Credit Scores

Credit scoring models calculate your credit score by considering several factors, including payment history, amounts owed, length of credit history, credit mix, and new credit inquiries. A collection account can stay on your credit report for up to seven years from the date of the original delinquency, and their presence can severely lower credit scores, especially for those with limited credit history.

However, the impact of collections on your credit score typically decreases over time, especially if you have a history of responsible credit use and on-time payments. As the collection account ages, it will have less influence on your credit score, and eventually, it will drop off your credit report altogether.

The Impact of Collections on Different Credit Scoring Models

Credit scoring models, such as FICO® Score and VantageScore®, have varying approaches to evaluating collections accounts. Understanding how these models view collections can provide insight into the potential impact of paying off collections on your credit score.

FICO® Score 8

FICO® Score 8 takes both paid and unpaid third-party collection accounts into consideration when calculating your credit score. However, it does not consider collections for amounts under $100 or collections related to medical bills.

FICO® Score 9 and 10

FICO® Score 9 and 10 do not consider third-party collection accounts that have been paid in full, treating them more favorably than unpaid collections. These models also weigh medical collections less heavily than non-medical collections, leading to a more favorable outcome for consumers with medical debt.

VantageScore® 3.0

VantageScore® 3.0 factors in collections when determining your credit score, but it does not consider paid collection accounts, treating them as neutral. Similar to FICO® Score 8, it does not consider collections for amounts under $100 or medical collection debt.

VantageScore® 4.0

VantageScore® 4.0 distinguishes medical collections from other types of collection accounts and places less emphasis on medical collections relative to other types of collections. Furthermore, the model ignores all collection accounts that have been paid in full.

Benefits of Paying Off Collections

Short-term Impact on Credit Score

Although paying off a collections account won’t immediately remove it from your credit reports, newer credit scoring models like FICO® Score 9, 10, and VantageScore® 4.0 may view it more favorably. Once a collection account is paid, it should be updated on your credit reports to reflect the change in status.

Long-term Impact on Credit Score

Paying off collections can also reduce your total debt, which can improve your credit utilization ratio. A lower credit utilization ratio can positively impact your credit score over time. Moreover, lenders may be more likely to extend credit to individuals with paid collections than those with unpaid collections.

Strategies for Paying Off Collections

Negotiate with Collection Agencies

You can negotiate with debt collectors by discussing settlement offers or payment plans. Settlement offers involve paying a lower amount than the original debt, saving you money and helping you resolve the debt faster. Payment plans can make the debt more manageable if you’re unable to pay the full amount.

Pay Off Newer Collections First

To prioritize collections for maximum credit score improvement, focus on paying off newer collections first, as they have a greater impact on your credit score. Tackle higher-balance collections first, as they contribute more to your overall debt and credit utilization ratio. Prioritize collections that will have the most significant impact on your credit score.

Removing Collections from Your Credit Report

Credit Report Disputes

Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), you are entitled to dispute inaccurate or outdated information on your credit report, including collections. If you believe a collection account on your report is erroneous, you can take the following steps to dispute it and potentially have it removed:

  1. Obtain your credit reports: Request a free copy of your credit report from each of the three major credit bureaus – Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion – to identify any errors or inaccuracies in your collection accounts.
  2. Gather documentation: Collect any documents, records, or correspondence that support your claim. This may include account statements, payment records, or communication with the original creditor or collection agency.
  3. File a dispute: Submit a formal dispute with each credit bureau that has included the incorrect information on your credit report. Include a detailed explanation of the error, along with copies of your supporting documentation. You can file disputes online, by mail, or over the phone.
  4. Monitor your credit reports: Keep an eye on your credit reports to ensure the dispute has been resolved, and any necessary corrections have been made. If the collection account is found to be inaccurate or outdated, it should be removed from your credit reports, which may improve your credit score.

Pay-for-Delete Agreements

Pay-for-delete agreements involve the collection agency agreeing to remove the collection account from your credit report in exchange for payment. While this may seem like a viable option, it’s important to note that pay-for-delete agreements are not always honored.

Request Removal with a Goodwill Letter

If you’ve settled the collection, consider writing a goodwill letter to your lender. If you have a longstanding relationship with a lender and the collection account resulted from a one-time oversight, you could consider writing a goodwill letter to request an exception.

In the letter, emphasize the length of your relationship with the lender, highlight your consistent payment history apart from this isolated incident, and assure them of your commitment to rectify the situation.

To preserve a positive rapport, request that they remove the collection from your credit report. Keep in mind that this approach is typically more effective if you have already paid off the debt, ensuring the lender hasn’t suffered any financial loss.

Preventing Collections and Maintaining a Healthy Credit Score

Establishing Good Financial Habits

Creating a budget can help you track your spending and ensure you can meet your debt payments on time. Regularly monitoring your credit reports for errors and signs of identity theft is also important. You can obtain free credit reports from the three major credit bureaus. Setting up payment reminders through tools and apps can help you remember upcoming debt payments.

Communicating with Creditors

Request payment arrangements or explore hardship programs to avoid having your debts sent to a debt collector. Communicating with creditors when you’re facing financial difficulties is essential.

Seeking Professional Help

Seeking professional help, such as credit repair companies, credit counseling, or debt management plans, can also be beneficial for managing your finances and maintaining a healthy credit score.

Building Credit Through Credit Builder Accounts

Credit builder accounts, such as secured credit cards or credit builder loans, can help you establish or rebuild your credit by reporting positive payment history to the credit bureaus. Using these tools responsibly can lead to an improved credit score over time.

Knowing Your Rights Under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) provides consumers with protection from abusive and unfair debt collection practices. Familiarize yourself with your rights under the FDCPA to ensure debt collectors treat you fairly and legally during the collections process.

Bottom Line

Paying off collections can improve your credit score by reducing your overall debt and improving your credit utilization ratio. While collection accounts may not be immediately removed from your credit report, it could be viewed more favorably by a newer credit scoring model or lender.

By establishing good financial habits, communicating with creditors, and seeking professional help, you can effectively manage your finances and maintain a healthy credit score. Understanding the different credit scoring models and their approach to collections will also enable you to make informed decisions that positively impact your credit score in the long run.

Meet the author

Crediful is your go-to destination for all things related to personal finance. We're dedicated to helping you achieve financial freedom and make informed financial decisions. Our team of financial experts and enthusiasts brings you articles and resources on topics like budgeting, credit, saving, investing, and more.